Updated Nov 19, 2026· 9 min read

Key takeaways

  • Discover the best ice cube trays for everyday drinks, cocktails, and iced coffee, with large cubes, easy release, lids, and stackable designs for freezers.

For most households, the best overall choice is the OXO Good Grips Covered Ice Cube Tray in the large-cube size. It makes six large, slow-melting cubes, includes a lid for stacking and odour protection, and uses flexible silicone inside a rigid frame, so cubes release without a struggle. The Tovolo King Cube is a strong classic alternative for whiskey and cocktails. The glacio two-pack is a practical mid-range pick for large cubes, the DOQAUS four-tray kit with a storage bin and scoop suits households that use a lot of ice, and the W and P Mini Ice Box is the best choice for small cubes in larger quantities.

Cube size, material, lid, and pack size are the four points that matter most. Large cubes melt slowly and suit whiskey, cocktails, and iced coffee. Standard and small cubes chill drinks quickly and suit pitchers, water, soda, and iced tea. Silicone flexes for easy release, while rigid plastic holds its shape better when a tray is full. A lid keeps freezer odours away and allows stacking, while a storage bin lets you collect frozen cubes and refill trays for the next batch.

Table of Contents

How to Choose the Best Ice Cube Trays

Begin with cube size. Large cubes, usually around two inches across, melt slowly, which helps whiskey, cocktails, and iced coffee stay cold without diluting quickly. Standard cubes chill a glass quickly and fit bottles and narrow glasses. Small cubes are useful when you need a lot of ice at once for a pitcher, a cooler, or a family meal.

Next, look at material. Silicone trays flex, so cubes can be pushed out from below without twisting a rigid tray until it cracks. Rigid plastic trays hold their shape better when full, which makes them easier to carry from sink to freezer. Some trays combine the two ideas, with a silicone mould inside a rigid frame, a design worth seeking out if wobbly silicone trays have caused spills before.

A lid keeps freezer odours away, keeps other items from falling in, and lets you stack trays without the upper tray touching the water below. A storage bin is a different kind of help: once cubes are frozen, you can empty the trays into the bin, refill the trays, and keep a larger supply ready. Pack size should match your routine. A single tray making six cubes suits one or two drinks, a two-pack doubles that output, a four-pack kit suits daily use, and a tray holding 48 small cubes suits volume.

OXO Good Grips Covered Ice Cube Tray, Large Cube

The OXO Good Grips Covered Ice Cube Tray in the large-cube size is the best overall pick here. It makes six large cubes, each measuring about 4.4 centimetres square, according to published listings. That size suits a rocks glass, a tumbler, and a wide cocktail glass, and it also works well in iced coffee, where a standard cube can melt before the drink is finished.

The mould is flexible silicone, so cubes release by pushing from below rather than by twisting a rigid tray. Around it is a rigid frame that keeps the tray steady while you carry it to the freezer, a detail that separates it from many all-silicone trays, which can wobble and spill when full. The lid covers the water while it freezes, helps prevent freezer odours from reaching the ice, and provides a flat surface for stacking. OXO lists the tray as dishwasher safe. The main limit is its single-tray format: six cubes suit a quiet evening, but a household serving several iced drinks at once will need more than one tray.

Specs

Feature Detail
Brand OXO
Product Good Grips Covered Ice Cube Tray, Large Cube
Material Silicone and plastic
Cubes per tray 6 large cubes
Cube size About 4.4 cm square
Lid Yes, included
Stackable Yes
Dishwasher safe Yes
Best for Cocktails, whiskey, and iced coffee

Tovolo King Cube Ice Trays

The Tovolo King Cube is the classic large-cube tray in this roundup. Each tray makes six cubes measuring two inches across, according to published listings, a good match for whiskey, bourbon, and cocktails where dilution should be kept to a minimum. The tray is made from silicone, which flexes to release cubes without the twisting and cracking that can affect rigid plastic trays. The material is listed as BPA-free, and the tray is listed as dishwasher safe.

The design is deliberately simple, with no storage bin, scoop, or sliding lid in the standard listing. A buyer who only needs large cubes for a small number of drinks will appreciate it, while a buyer who needs a lid or a bin should look at another tray here. In the budget to mid-range group, the King Cube is a practical choice for a home bar.

Specs

Feature Detail
Brand Tovolo
Product King Cube Ice Trays
Material Silicone
Cubes per tray 6 large cubes
Cube size 2 inches
BPA-free Yes, as listed
Dishwasher safe Yes
Best for Whiskey, bourbon, and cocktails

glacio Large Cube Tray, 2-Pack

The glacio Large Cube Tray is sold as a two-pack, a useful mid-range choice for households that want large cubes for more than one drink at a time. The set makes eight large square cubes in total, according to the published listing, enough for two cocktails or iced coffees in one freezing round. The trays are made from silicone, so cubes can be pushed out from below, and the large square shape is designed to melt slowly.

The listing describes the trays as suitable for whiskey, cocktails, coffee, and other cold drinks. The two-pack format is the main advantage: you can freeze a larger batch, and keep one tray in the freezer while the other is being washed or refilled. The set does not include a storage bin or a scoop, and the listing does not describe a lid in the same way as the OXO or DOQAUS trays. For a buyer who wants a simple, flexible two-pack of large-cube trays, glacio is a solid choice.

Specs

Feature Detail
Brand glacio
Product Large Cube Tray, 2-Pack
Material Silicone
Pack size 2 trays
Total cubes 8 large square cubes
Cube shape Square
Best for Whiskey, cocktails, coffee, and iced drinks

DOQAUS Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin, 4-Pack

The DOQAUS Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin is the high-capacity choice here. It is sold as a four-pack kit, and the published listing describes a complete set: four silicone ice trays, four spill-resistant lids, one storage bin with a lid, and one ice scoop. You freeze cubes in the trays, empty them into the bin, refill the trays, and serve from the bin with the scoop.

Each tray is made from silicone, so cubes release by pushing from below. The lids help prevent spills when a full tray is carried to the freezer and help keep freezer odours away from the ice. The trays are listed as stackable, which matters when four trays need to fit in a freezer at once. The listing describes the trays as BPA-free, and the silicone construction is suitable for cocktails, coffee, soup, and food, according to the published description, as long as food and ice are kept separate to avoid flavour transfer. The main trade-off is size: four trays, a bin, and a scoop take up more freezer space than a single tray, and the kit has more parts to wash and store.

Specs

Feature Detail
Brand DOQAUS
Product Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin, 4-Pack
Material Silicone
Pack size 4 trays, 1 storage bin, 1 scoop
Lids Yes, 4 spill-resistant lids included
Storage bin Yes, with lid
Stackable Yes
BPA-free Yes, as listed
Best for Everyday ice, families, and larger batches

W and P Mini Ice Box Silicone Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin

The W and P Mini Ice Box is the small-cube, high-volume choice here. It is a silicone tray with a lid and a bin, designed to hold 48 small cubes, according to the published listing. That capacity makes it useful for pitchers, coolers, water bottles, and gatherings where many glasses need ice at once. Small cubes chill a drink quickly, and 48 cubes cover several servings without refilling the tray in the middle of a meal.

The tray is made from silicone, so cubes release easily, and it is listed as dishwasher safe. The lid helps keep the ice clean and allows the tray to be stacked, which saves space in a crowded freezer. The bin provides a place to store frozen cubes once they are released, so the tray can be refilled for the next batch. The Mini Ice Box is described as space-saving and stackable, which suits a smaller freezer. The main limit is cube size: small cubes melt faster than large cubes, so this tray is not the best choice for a whiskey or cocktail that should stay undiluted.

Specs

Feature Detail
Brand W and P
Product Mini Ice Box Silicone Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin
Material Silicone
Capacity Holds 48 cubes
Lid Yes, included
Storage bin Yes, included
Stackable Yes
Dishwasher safe Yes
Best for Everyday drinks, pitchers, and larger groups

Frequently Asked Questions

What size ice cube tray is best for cocktails?

A large-cube tray is usually best for cocktails, because a large cube melts more slowly and dilutes the drink less. Trays that make cubes around two inches across, such as the OXO large-cube tray and the Tovolo King Cube, are a good match for whiskey and other drinks served over ice. For a cocktail in a tall glass, a standard cube may fit better, so glass size should guide the choice as well.

Are silicone ice cube trays better than plastic trays?

Silicone trays are usually easier for release, because the flexible material allows cubes to be pushed out from below without twisting the tray. Plastic trays are usually more rigid, which makes them easier to carry when full, but they can crack over time and cubes can stick. A hybrid tray with a silicone mould and a rigid frame combines the strengths of both materials.

Do ice cube trays need a lid?

A lid is not essential, but it is useful in most freezers. It helps keep freezer odours away from the ice, keeps other items from falling into the tray, and allows trays to be stacked without touching the water below. It also helps prevent spills when a full tray is carried from the sink to the freezer. If your freezer is crowded, a lid is worth choosing.

How do you keep ice cubes from tasting like the freezer?

Use a tray with a lid, store frozen cubes in a covered bin once they are released, and keep ice away from uncovered food with a strong smell. Wash trays regularly, allow them to dry fully before refilling, and replace a tray if it has absorbed odours that do not wash out. A covered bin, such as the ones included with the DOQAUS kit and the W and P Mini Ice Box, helps keep stored cubes clean.

Conclusion

The best ice cube tray depends on the drink, the number of servings, and the space in your freezer. For most buyers, the OXO large-cube tray is the best overall choice, combining large, slow-melting cubes with flexible silicone, a rigid frame, a lid, and stackable storage. The Tovolo King Cube is a strong classic alternative, while the glacio two-pack is a practical mid-range choice for more than one drink at a time. For volume, the DOQAUS four-pack kit is the most complete option, and the W and P Mini Ice Box is the best compact choice for 48 small cubes. Choose large cubes for cocktails and iced coffee, small cubes for pitchers and everyday drinks, and a lid and a bin whenever you want cleaner ice and a larger ready supply.

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

|—|—|

A
admin
We compare specs, materials and verified owner reviews before a product earns a spot. Rankings are never paid.
Affiliate disclosure. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Prices accurate as of the date shown.